Linking Shopify to Etsy: Integration Benefits, Comparisons, and Profitable Items

In today’s fast-paced e-commerce world, online sellers are constantly seeking ways to expand their reach and streamline their business processes. One effective way to achieve this is by linking Shopify to Etsy. These two platforms, while having their own unique features, can complement each other and create a seamless shopping experience for both sellers and customers. In this article, we will discuss the importance of integrating Shopify and Etsy, as well as the benefits that come with this powerful combination.

TL;DR

• Linking Shopify and Etsy increases exposure and reaches a dedicated customer base
• Compare platforms to determine which suits your needs and goals
• Etsy allows drop shipping under specific conditions
• Import listings to Etsy easily with the CSV import feature
• Etsy faces competition from Amazon Handmade, Shopify, and eBay
• Etsy remains valuable in 2023 for handmade, vintage, or unique items sellers

Importance of linking Shopify to Etsy

By linking your Shopify store to your Etsy shop, you can tap into a vast pool of potential customers and gain access to Etsy’s thriving marketplace, which is known for its focus on handmade, vintage, and unique items. This connection can help you broaden your market and increase your sales, especially if you offer products that align with Etsy’s target audience.

Furthermore, integrating Shopify with Etsy brings several benefits that can make managing your online business much more efficient. Some of these advantages include centralized inventory management, streamlined order processing, and the ability to synchronize product listings across both platforms. This not only saves you time but also helps to reduce the risk of overselling or running out of stock.

In the following sections, we will dive deeper into the process of connecting Shopify to Etsy, the differences and similarities between the two platforms, and various considerations to keep in mind when selling on both platforms. Whether you’re new to e-commerce or a seasoned seller, this guide will provide valuable insights to help you make the most of both Shopify and Etsy.

Connecting Shopify to Etsy

Yes, it is possible to connect your Shopify store to Etsy, allowing you to manage products, orders, and inventory across both platforms with ease. By linking the two, you can reach a wider audience and take advantage of the unique features each platform offers.

Let’s walk through the process of connecting your Shopify store to Etsy and adding Etsy products to your Shopify store.

Can I connect my Shopify store to Etsy?

To connect your Shopify store to Etsy, you can use an integration app available in the Shopify App Store. One popular option is the Etsy Marketplace Integration app, which helps to synchronize your product listings, inventory, and orders between the two platforms.

How to link your online store to Etsy

Here’s a step-by-step guide to linking your Shopify store to Etsy using the Etsy Marketplace Integration app:

1. Sign up for a Shopify account (if you haven’t already) and create your online store.
2. Set up an Etsy seller account (if you don’t have one) and configure your shop settings.
3. Visit the Shopify App Store and search for the “Etsy Marketplace Integration” app.
4. Click “Add app” and follow the prompts to install the app in your Shopify store.
5. Once installed, open the app and click “Connect to Etsy” to authorize the app to access your Etsy account.
6. Follow the on-screen instructions to configure the integration settings, such as product syncing, inventory management, and order processing.

How to add Etsy products to Shopify

Once you have connected your Shopify store to Etsy, you can add Etsy products to your Shopify store by following these steps:

1. In the Etsy Marketplace Integration app dashboard, click on the “Products” tab.
2. Select the Etsy products you want to add to your Shopify store.
3. Click “Actions” and choose “Export to Shopify” from the dropdown menu.
4. The app will then sync the selected Etsy products to your Shopify store, including product titles, descriptions, images, and prices.

Remember that when adding products from Etsy to Shopify, it’s important to ensure that your product listings comply with Shopify’s policies and guidelines.

By linking your Shopify store to Etsy, you can efficiently manage your business across both platforms and take advantage of the unique opportunities each platform offers.

For example, you might use Shopify for a more customizable online store and Etsy to tap into its community of buyers who appreciate handmade, vintage, and unique items.

Comparing Shopify and Etsy

Is it better to do Shopify or Etsy?

Choosing between Shopify and Etsy depends on your specific needs, goals, and the nature of your business. Both platforms have their own advantages and disadvantages, so it’s essential to evaluate which one is better suited for your online store.

Shopify is a powerful e-commerce platform that allows you to create a customizable online store with various themes, apps, and features. It’s an excellent choice for entrepreneurs who want full control over their store’s design and functionality. Shopify also supports a wide range of products and services, making it suitable for different types of businesses.

On the other hand, Etsy is a marketplace that focuses primarily on handmade, vintage, and unique items. It offers a built-in audience of shoppers who are specifically looking for these types of products. As a result, Etsy can be a better choice for sellers who create unique, handcrafted items or sell vintage products.

How much does Shopify take per sale vs Etsy?

Shopify and Etsy have different fee structures for their sellers:

Shopify charges a monthly subscription fee, which varies depending on the plan you choose (Basic Shopify, Shopify, or Advanced Shopify). The plans range from $29 to $299 per month. Additionally, Shopify charges a transaction fee for each sale, which ranges from 2.9% + 30¢ to 2.4% + 30¢, depending on the plan. If you use Shopify Payments, you can avoid additional transaction fees.

Etsy charges a $0.20 listing fee per item and a 5% transaction fee for each sale. If you use Etsy Payments, there is also a payment processing fee, which varies by country. For example, in the US, the fee is 3% + 25¢ per transaction.

Etsy’s weaknesses and why people are moving to Shopify

While Etsy has a loyal customer base and a strong focus on unique and handmade items, there are some weaknesses that may prompt sellers to consider moving to Shopify:

1. Limited customization: Etsy shops have limited customization options compared to Shopify stores, making it challenging for sellers to create a distinctive brand identity on the platform.
2. High competition: Etsy’s marketplace can be highly competitive, as sellers must vie for attention among thousands of other shops offering similar products.
3. Fees: Some sellers may find Etsy’s fees, including listing, transaction, and payment processing fees, to be too high and prefer Shopify’s fee structure.
4. Product restrictions: Etsy’s focus on handmade, vintage and unique items means that sellers who wish to expand their product offerings may be limited on the platform.
5. Lack of ownership: With Etsy, sellers don’t have complete control or ownership over their shop, as they are subject to Etsy’s policies and guidelines. Shopify provides sellers with more autonomy over their stores and their operations.

In conclusion, the decision to use Shopify or Etsy depends on your specific business needs and goals. By understanding the advantages and disadvantages of each platform, you can make an informed choice and find the best solution for your online store.

Dropshipping and Importing Listings

Does Etsy allow dropshipping?

Etsy does allow dropshipping under certain conditions. According to their guidelines, the seller must be involved in the design or creation process of the items they’re selling. Additionally, they must accurately represent their role in the production process and disclose their production partners (the manufacturers or drop shippers) in their Etsy shop’s “About” section. It’s essential to review Etsy’s policies on dropshipping and ensure that your business model complies with their guidelines.

Can you dropship Etsy products on Shopify?

Dropshipping Etsy products on Shopify is not a common practice, as most Etsy items are handmade, vintage, or unique and don’t fit the typical dropshipping model. However, if you find a compliant Etsy seller who is willing to partner with you as a dropshipper, you can consider using their products in your Shopify store. In such cases, it’s crucial to maintain transparent communication with the Etsy seller and ensure that your Shopify store complies with all relevant policies and guidelines.

Importing listings into Etsy

If you’re moving your products from another platform to Etsy or want to bulk upload your products, you can use Etsy’s CSV (comma-separated values) import feature. Here’s a step-by-step guide to importing listings into Etsy:

1. Log in to your Etsy account and go to the “Shop Manager.”
2. Click on “Listings” in the left-hand menu and then click on the gear icon in the top right corner.
3. Choose “Import from a CSV file” from the dropdown menu.
4. Download Etsy’s CSV template and fill it with your product information, following the guidelines provided. You can also export your product listings from your previous platform (such as Shopify) and reformat the CSV file to match Etsy’s template.
5. Once you have prepared your CSV file, return to the “Import from a CSV file” page on Etsy and click “Choose File” to upload your CSV file.
6. Click “Upload and continue” to start the import process. Etsy will notify you once the import is complete.

Keep in mind that you must follow Etsy’s policies and guidelines when importing listings, especially when it comes to product categories and the types of items allowed on the platform.

In summary, while Etsy does allow dropshipping under specific conditions, it’s not common to dropship Etsy products on Shopify due to the nature of Etsy items. Importing listings into Etsy is a straightforward process using their CSV import feature, allowing sellers to easily transition from other platforms or bulk upload their products.

Etsy vs. Competitors

Etsy’s biggest competitor

Etsy’s biggest competitor is arguably Amazon Handmade, a marketplace created by Amazon specifically for artisans to sell their handcrafted products. Launched in 2015, Amazon Handmade offers a similar focus on unique, handmade items, and appeals to a broad audience due to Amazon’s massive customer base. While Amazon Handmade is a significant competitor to Etsy, it’s worth noting that each platform has its own unique features and benefits, attracting different sellers and customers.

Platforms better than Etsy

Saying that a platform is “better” than Etsy depends on a seller’s specific needs and goals. There are several alternatives to Etsy, each with its unique features and target audience. Some of these platforms include:

1. Shopify: As discussed earlier, Shopify is an e-commerce platform that allows sellers to create customizable online stores. Shopify is a great alternative for sellers who want more control over their store’s design and functionality, as well as the ability to sell a broader range of products and services.
2. Amazon Handmade: As mentioned previously, Amazon Handmade is a direct competitor to Etsy, focusing on handmade and unique items. Amazon Handmade may be a better fit for sellers who want to leverage Amazon’s vast customer base and take advantage of their Fulfillment by Amazon (FBA) service.
3. eBay: eBay is another online marketplace that allows sellers to list a wide variety of products, including handmade and vintage items. eBay’s auction-style format may appeal to sellers who want to reach a different type of buyer or sell unique items at potentially higher prices.
4. Bonanza: Bonanza is an online marketplace that emphasizes ease of use and simplicity for sellers. Like Etsy, Bonanza focuses on unique items, handmade goods, and vintage products. Bonanza might be a better fit for sellers looking for a smaller, more community-oriented marketplace.
5. Big Cartel: Big Cartel is an e-commerce platform tailored to artists and makers who want to sell their creations online. With a focus on simplicity and ease of use, Big Cartel could be a better fit for sellers who want a more streamlined experience and a platform specifically designed for artists.

Ultimately, the “best” platform for a seller depends on their individual needs, goals, and the type of products they sell. By researching and comparing the features, benefits, and target audiences of each platform, sellers can make an informed decision and find the most suitable marketplace for their online store.

Etsy’s Value in 2023

Is Etsy still worth it in 2023?

In 2023, Etsy remains a valuable platform for sellers who create handmade, vintage, or unique items. With its dedicated customer base and focus on specialized products, Etsy continues to provide opportunities for sellers to reach a global audience that appreciates and values their craftsmanship. While competition and fees can be challenging, Etsy’s niche appeal and supportive community make it an attractive option for many sellers.

However, it’s essential to consider your specific business needs and goals when deciding if Etsy is the right platform for you. For some sellers, alternatives like Shopify, Amazon Handmade, or other online marketplaces may be more suitable, offering greater flexibility or a different target audience.

What are the most profitable items to sell on Etsy?

The most profitable items to sell on Etsy can vary depending on factors like demand, competition, and production costs. However, some popular and potentially profitable categories on Etsy include:

1. Personalized and custom items: Customized products, such as jewellery, clothing, or home decor, often have a higher perceived value and can command higher prices. Additionally, personalized items are less likely to face direct competition, as each piece is unique.
2. Handmade jewellery: Handcrafted jewellery remains popular on Etsy, with many shoppers seeking unique, one-of-a-kind pieces. High-quality materials and original designs can help set your jewellery apart and command higher prices.
3. Digital products: Digital items, such as printable art, digital planners, or graphic design templates, have the advantage of low production costs and no shipping expenses. This can result in higher profit margins for sellers.
4. Wedding-related items: The wedding industry is continually growing, and Etsy is a popular destination for couples looking for unique, handcrafted items for their special day. Wedding invitations, decor, and personalized gifts can be particularly profitable.
5. Art and illustrations: Original art and illustrations, especially those that can be customized or personalized, can command high prices on Etsy. Offering a range of sizes, formats, or personalization options can help attract a wider audience.

It’s important to note that finding the most profitable items to sell on Etsy involves researching your target market, identifying trends, and staying aware of your production costs and competition. By focusing on creating high-quality, unique products that cater to a specific audience, you can increase your chances of success on Etsy in 2023 and beyond.

Conclusion

Summary of key points

In this article, we’ve covered the following key points:

1. Connecting your Shopify store to Etsy can help you reach a broader audience and tap into Etsy’s dedicated customer base.
2. Comparing Shopify and Etsy is essential to determine which platform is best suited for your unique needs and goals.
3. Dropshipping on Etsy is allowed under specific conditions, but dropshipping Etsy products on Shopify is less common due to the nature of Etsy items.
4. Importing listings into Etsy is a straightforward process using their CSV import feature.
5. Etsy faces competition from other platforms like Amazon Handmade, Shopify, and eBay, with each platform offering unique features and target audiences.
6. Etsy remains a valuable platform for sellers in 2023, particularly for those who create handmade, vintage, or unique items.

Final thoughts on linking Shopify to Etsy

Linking your Shopify store to Etsy can provide several benefits, including increased exposure and the opportunity to tap into a dedicated customer base seeking unique and handcrafted items. However, it’s crucial to consider your specific business needs, goals, and the type of products you sell when deciding whether to integrate your Shopify store with Etsy or explore alternative platforms.

By researching and comparing the features, benefits, and target audiences of different online marketplaces, you can make an informed decision and find the most suitable platform to help your business grow and succeed. Ultimately, the key to success in online selling is understanding your target market, offering high-quality products, and adapting to the ever-changing e-commerce landscape.

Frequently Asked Questions